Daniel Farke’s loyalty to those in his Leeds United starting XI is admirable even if it means sticking with players that are out of form, such as Brenden Aaronson and Illan Meslier.
But it means those not in and around the starting XI are made to wait for a chance. Willy Gnonto has not started a league game in 2025, though Graham Smyth thinks Gnonto will start against Luton on Saturday.
For those not on the fringes and have two or more players above them in the pecking order, it is almost impossible to make a breakthrough. Isaac Schmidt has failed to start a league game for Leeds this season.
Even if, he has been called up by Switzerland and won senior caps in the last few weeks. Charlie Cresswell was forced to search for pastures new last summer and Joe Gelhardt left the club on loan in January.
Leeds told Joe Gelhardt has been unhappy ever since Farke joined
It is five years since Leeds signed Gelhardt from cash-strapped Wigan for just £1m under Marcelo Bielsa. Alan Shearer have described Gelhardt as “magic” on Match of the Day in 2022, starring in the 21’s initially.
He made that first-team breakthrough under Bielsa and continued with Jesse Marsch at the helm. A drop to the Championship was seen as a possible benefit to players like Gelhardt and Crysencio Summerville.
But it never worked out, Gelhardt managing just two Championship starts under Farke since the German’s arrival. They came back in August 2023, and in January of this year, Gelhardt joined Hull City on loan.
Starring at Hull, teammate Kyle Joseph told Hull Live that Gelhardt has been unhappy for the last couple of years: “He’s obviously had a difficult time at Leeds in terms of the way he hasn’t really played much.
“When he has played, he’s made a really good impact when he played in the Premier League. Now, he’s probably found somewhere he can call home, where he feels appreciated, can come in and be himself.
“Sometimes off-the-pitch stuff means a lot more. I think that’s been the case with ‘Joff’. He’s been happy off the pitch for the first time in a couple of years. He’s doing really well, he’s happy. Been good to see.”
Kyle Joseph desperate for permanent Joe Gelhardt signing at Hull
Making 13 appearances for Hull since his arrival under Ruben Selles, Gelhardt has scored three goals and become a bit of a fan favourite. Indeed, Gelhardt scored a stunning volley to open his account for Hull.
Hull fans are desperate for Gelhardt to join permanently, and it appears his teammate Joseph is also keen. Joseph says he is trying to convince Gelhardt to sign on “every day”, alongside another in Charlie Hughes.
“We’re in his ear every day, me and Chaz (Charlie Hughes), but no, it’s like he says, he loves it here, he’s enjoying it, and that’s the main thing. There’ll be something that happens in the summer,” he said.
“I think there’ll be a conversation to be had, and it’ll be based on different things, but no, it’ll be good to keep that close relationship with ‘Joff’ and, yes, fingers crossed he does come back,” Joseph continued.
Hull boss Selles says a permanent deal is a possibility, while Lee Hendrie has urged Gelhardt to leave Leeds and sign for Hull. If he continues to shine on loan, a permanent deal looks more and more likely.
Receive a digest of our best Leeds content each week direct to your mailbox
