Opinion

Marcelo Bielsa’s ‘toxic’ admission shows 49ers why a Leeds United return would not work

Add as preferred source on Google

Former Leeds United manager Marcelo Bielsa has ended the immediate speculation surrounding his future with a dramatic press conference overnight.

A heavy defeat against the USA ramped up the pressure on Uruguay manager Marcelo Bielsa, who addressed the media on the evening of 20th November.

However, Bielsa did not resign, as some reports speculated he might. Instead, he reiterated his commitment to taking Uruguay to the World Cup.

Bielsa’s press conference also ends any prospect of a shock return to Leeds, as his successor, Daniel Farke, fights for his future at the club.

Whilst the romance of a potential Bielsa return is intoxicating, his frank assessment of his “toxic” personality shows why the 49ers should not consider bringing him back to West Yorkshire.

Leeds United legend Marcelo Bielsa could be on the market after the World Cup. Is the time right for him to come back to Elland Road?

Marcelo Bielsa during a Uruguay press conference
Photo by Guillermo Legaria/Getty Images

Marcelo Bielsa gives frank assessment of his ‘toxic’ personality

Speaking in his press conference, via El Observador, Bielsa dissected his own personality, offering an insight into what motivates him to succeed.

Describing himself as “toxic”, Bielsa described how a fear of failure fuelled his obsession with football, as opposed to the chance for victory. Bielsa said: “I always use one word: I’m toxic. Being around me makes the person I’m around worse. Toxic.

“There are toxic types who only see mistakes, who are always correcting, demanding, never satisfied with anything, who only like to talk about work, who go out to eat and keep a diary because they don’t want to integrate with the rest of the team and don’t want to talk about things that might distance them.

“I see it as karma. That behaviour is based on fear; you don’t enjoy winning, you fear losing, much more than you enjoy winning. That obsession lies in the search for resources that move you away from defeat and closer to victory.”

Marcelo Bielsa during United States v Uruguay - International Friendly
Photo by Edgardo Medina/NurPhoto via Getty Images

Former Leeds United boss takes aim ‘cowards’ in the Uruguay squad

Bielsa also gave an insight into how he uses criticism as a tool to motivate his players, amid reports of disharmony in the Uruguay squad.

According to Bielsa, he has accused players in his squad of being “cowards” who have not made the most of their ability. The former Leeds boss believes that these “extreme blows” can be a powerful motivational tool.

He explained: “I’m a big source of tension, so I don’t mesh well with others. That’s why I isolate myself and go it alone when necessary. It happened, and I’m not going to tell you with whom.

Bielsa added: “When you lose your inhibitions with someone, you tell them, ‘Look, you’re a coward,’ because you’re full of resources, but you never translate those resources into dangerous actions. You know how that’s defined? It means you’re a coward.

Daniel Farke and Marcelo Bielsa’s Leeds numbers make for interesting reading 🤔

Daniel Farke

Marcelo Bielsa

Daniel Farke of Leeds United (left) and Argentinian Marcelo Bielsa (right)
Credit: Harry Murphy/George Wood via Getty Images

“If you’re going to keep being a coward, you’re going to keep being mediocre, because you’re a great player in terms of your qualities, but you’re a coward when it comes to translating or imposing those qualities.

“It has an extraordinary effect. The player enters the field like a lion. Those extreme blows are a motivator.”

49ers cannot afford to take Marcelo Bielsa gamble with Leeds United

For Leeds United fans watching Bielsa’s Uruguayan drama unfolding, it is a reminder of the emotional rollercoaster that accompanies the near-messianic Argentinian.

When Andrea Radrizzani and Victor Orta convinced Bielsa to join Leeds, the club needed an innovator who could break the cycle of mediocrity that had enveloped Elland Road following relegation in 2004.

However, Bielsa’s reign was fraught with turmoil, as Leeds rode the wave of his genius. Having lifted the lid on his motivational techniques and personality traits, it is easy to see why his impact diminishes over time.

For better and for worse, the 49ers operate with a different approach to Radrizzani and Orta. Paraag Marathe and his leadership team like to present themselves as a sober, rational machine, making decisions based on data.

Leeds and Bielsa were the perfect marriage in 2018: two throwbacks from another era, raging against the machine with an exhilarating and uncompromising brand of attacking football.

But Bielsa and the 49ers’ partnership could not work. Although the pull of nostalgia remains strong, a return for Bielsa would only risk damaging the treasured memories Leeds fans hold of their former manager.